- Home
- Administrative data
- Our research
- About us
- Contact us
- News and events
- BLOG - Access to secure data during the Covid-19 pandemic - a model for the future?
- Covid-19 and Care Homes: Advances in Administrative Data Research during the pandemic
- DATA INSIGHTS -Deprivation and informal care at the end of life
- BLOG - Reflections on engaging with children & young people about data
- NEWS - Innovative new residential linkage tool launched
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home- No.4
- DATA INSIGHTS - Youth Movements, Social Mobility and Health Inequalities
- NEWS - New report warns of deepening poverty crisis for Scottish families
- New report on Infants Born into Care in Scotland
- Spotlight on Dr Elizabeth Lemmon
- Spotlight on Jan Savinc
- BLOG - Covid-19 fines in Scotland: What we know so far
- BLOG - The value of social science and administrative data research in Scotland: how we are helping respond to COVID-19
- NEWS - Joining together with Research Data Scotland to co-host existing public panel on data
- DATA INSIGHTS - Exploring illegal drug consignments in Scotland
- DATA INSIGHTS -Linking two administrative data sets about looked after children
- NEWS - ADR UK grants 20 PhD studentship opportunities focused on quantitative research using linked administrative data
- NEWS – ADR Scotland data ambassadors launched
- Spotlight on Peter Christen
- The importance of administrative data
- Virtual Conference - Data Linkage: Information to Impact
- An Introduction to Data Science for Administrative Data Research course - March 2023
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home - No.7
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home- No.3
- DATA INSIGHTS - Investigating the effects of class composition and class size on pupils’ attainment in Scottish primary schools
- NEWS - New opportunity to join ADR Scotland’s Public Panel
- BLOG - Engaging the public through our public panel
- BLOG - Exploring the potential of synthetic data
- Children’s Health in Care in Scotland (CHiCS)
- DATA INSIGHTS - Automatic Coding of Occupations: Methods to create the Scottish Historic Population Database (SHPD)
- DATA INSIGHTS - Selective schools: do they improve health?
- DATA INSIGHTS - Were people who died at home less likely to attend hospital at the end of life during the Covid pandemic?
- EVENT - Active Travel: New Data, New Insights
- EVENT - Holyrood Evidence Week: Doing Data Better for Policy and Public Good
- EVENT - Unlocking criminal justice data in Scotland: Findings from Data First
- IPDLN Conference - Data linkage research: informing policy and practice
- NEWS - Making nursing data available to inform policy
- NEWS - New report on The Impact of Covid-19 on Children’s Care Journeys in Scotland: An Analysis of the Administrative Data on 'Looked After' Children
- NEWS - Updated report on Infants Born into Care in Scotland
- Scout and Guide participation boosts later life health
- BLOG - Geospatial Ambitions
- BLOG - Taking historical death records and developing a database for future analysis
- BLOG - Unlocking criminal justice data
- DATA INSIGHTS - Community mortality due to Covid-19
- DATA INSIGHTS - What makes people more likely to cycle to work?
- Future-proofing investment into administrative data research announced in Scotland
- NEWS - Understanding the dynamics of the nursing workforce: the potential of routinely collected data
- Spotlight on Joanna Soraghan
- Spotlight on Katherine Falconer
- Why misconceptions about population data can lead to bad outcomes
- ADR Scotland publishes its strategy for 2022-2026
- BLOG - Developing and re-shaping our public panel
- BLOG - Review of the recent DWP Areas of Research Interest Workshop
- BLOG: Developing a cross-national research agenda on crime and convictions
- BLOG: Working together to make a difference with data
- DATA INSIGHTS - Homelessness duration in Scotland: how long does rehousing take?
- DATA INSIGHTS - Occupation and COVID-19 deaths: Scotland in a comparative perspective
- DATA INSIGHTS -The health and economic benefits of active commuting in Scotland
- EVENT - ADR UK Conference 2023
- EVENT - RSE The secret world of data
- NEWS - New comic on children's rights and data
- NEWS - Report published on our children’s engagement pilot study
- NEWS - When did fines issued by the police for breaking Covid rules peak?
- Scotland’s portfolios: Research and Statistical Data - building a new approach to thematic data linkage
- Spotlight on Cecilia Macintyre
- Spotlight on Dr Evan Williams
- Spotlight on Fernando Pantoja
- Spotlight on Laurie Berrie
- ADR Scotland Winter Partnership Session - **internal event**
- BLOG - AGEING AND HOMELESSNESS IN SCOTLAND
- BLOG - Can we use linked administrative data to identify social disadvantage?
- BLOG - Commuting and its impact on health
- BLOG - The Dynamics of the Nursing Workforce in the UK: Using data to support our nurses
- BLOG: Growing up in kinship care
- Congratulations to Alastair McAlpine, the new Chief Statistician for Scottish Government
- DATA INSIGHTS - Analysing a season of death and excess mortality in Scotland’s past
- EVENT - ADR UK Virtual Half Day event
- EVENT - HDR UK Conference: Data for global health and society
- EVENT - Introduction to Data Science for Administrative Data Research course (IDS-ADR)
- Event - Public data for public good: towards better understanding children's lives
- NEWS - ADR Scotland's first flagship dataset
- NEWS - Data research initiative secures £90 m funding extension
- NEWS: Our role supporting the new Covid-19 research data service in Scotland
- Spotlight on Gina Anghelescu
- Spotlight on Michelle K Jamieson
- Webinar - An Introduction to Looked-After Children Dataset
- ADR Scotland Away Day (**for staff only**)
- BLOG - An Inside Job: Using Criminology, Police Data and a Lot of Nouse
- BLOG - Improving justice data to promote data justice in Scotland
- BLOG - Location of death in 2020: a changing trend from hospitals to homes
- BLOG - Reflecting on the ADR UK Conference: Insights from our new PhD Researchers
- BLOG - Seeking feedback on Research Data Scotland’s core principles via our public panel
- BLOG - What skills, training and support are required by those wishing a career as an administrative data researcher?
- BLOG No. 9 - Final blog in this 'deaths at home' series
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home - No. 6
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home - No.8
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home- No.5
- BLOG: 5 things I've learnt about working with policymakers...
- BLOG: Automating Coding for Large Historical Datasets
- BLOG: COVID-19- How increased deaths at home impact the carer community
- DATA INSIGHTS -Postal deliveries of drugs in Scotland
- EVENT - 'Getting things done with data in government'
- EVENT - Linking public sector data for research: an ADR UK showcase event
- EVENT Seminar - Administrative data for social policy research: potential and pitfalls
- NEWS - ADR Scotland launches new podcast series
- NEWS - Additional funding for Understanding Children’s Lives and Outcomes
- NEWS - Engaging children and young people
- NEWS: Police use of Fixed Penalty Notices under the Covid-19 regulations in Scotland: A new data report highlights links with deprivation and inequality
- NEWS: Police use of the new Covid-19 powers: Using administrative data to analyse and evaluate practice
- Research Data Scotland - New user forum
- Spotlight on Dr Patricio Troncoso
- Spotlight on Renata Samulnik
- Summary of ADR Scotland Winter Partnership session
- Directorship of the International Population Data Linkage Network (IPDLN) for 2021-22.
- BLOG: In the light of experience: InterRAI and the final thousand days of life
- Multiple health conditions and social care
- NEWS - Susan McVie elected as Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences
- SCADR relocates to the Bayes Centre
- EVENT: Four day introduction to using administrative data for social and health research
- BLOG: The value of administrative data: DALYs and the Scottish Burden of Disease study
- BLOG: Where to start with parliamentary and policy engagement
- EVENT - International Conference on Administrative Data Research, Cardiff
- EVENT - Using data to realise the potential of the 'Last 1000 days'
- EVENT: TalkingData: ADR Scotland mini-summit
- EVENT: “Let’s use data to save time, money and lives”: ADR Scotland partners gather for mini-summit
- EVENTS: ADR Scotland researchers present at international conference in Cardiff
BLOG - Developing a cross-national research agenda on crime and convictions: When will we catch up with our Scandinavian neighbours?
In this blog Professor Susan McVie and Dr Ben Matthews from our centre share reflections following their recent study visit to Stockholm, Sweden.
-
UK-based criminologists who work with linked administrative datasets often cast an envious eye over to the Scandinavian countries, where information about an individual’s criminal convictions is securely linked together with a wide range of other personal data through ‘register’ based systems.
This means that researching changing patterns of conviction, the impact of justice policies, alternative sentencing practices or potential causes of offending in Sweden, Norway, Finland and Denmark can be a fairly straightforward process and has yielded many interesting and policy-relevant results. Whereas, back in the UK, we are currently unable to ask any of the same research questions because data about criminal convictions are not routinely linked to any other administrative datasets.
So when we were invited to Stockholm to attend a workshop on register-based criminological research in Northern Europe we jumped at the chance. The opportunity to discuss criminological research based entirely on administrative sources of data, compare methodological approaches and discuss possibilities for comparative analyses was too much to resist!
Studies from Scandinavia and the Netherlands
The workshop focused on sharing research findings from criminological studies that were conducted exclusively using linked administrative datasets. Teams of researchers from Scandinavia and the Netherlands presented a range of research projects that were of significant policy importance, including: the feasibility (and desirability) of predicting youth crime at the year of birth in Norway; the effect of parental imprisonment on children’s criminal offending in Sweden; detecting bias in policing through data in Sweden; and the changing socio-demographics of convicted offenders in Finland.
One presentation that was of particular relevance and importance to policy and practice in Scotland was presented by Hilde Wermink from the Netherlands. She had used linked data to compare reconviction rates for people given short-term sentences with those given prison sentences, a highly topical subject in Scotland. She explained that just comparing the crude reconviction rates for these two types of sentences was like comparing apples to oranges (because differences in sentences were likely to reflect differences in their characteristics and offending history). To make an ‘apples to apples’ comparison, Hilde had adjusted for differences in the characteristics of the two groups and found that people who were given community sentences had a lower reconviction rate than similar people who received short prison sentences. Being able to replicate such a study in Scotland, and test the impact of different non-custodial disposals, could provide strong support for reducing the prison population!
Another benefit of attending was that we could highlight where research using administrative data in other countries had had an impact on policy developments in Scotland. For example, Britt Østergaard Larsen described a study to test the impact of reducing the age of criminal responsibility from 15 to 14 using a ‘natural experiment’ approach in Denmark. Using data on convictions, they found no evidence of a deterrence effect (that is, the threat of being dealt with in the criminal justice system did not lead to a reduction in the conviction rate). However, being convicted did itself lead to a higher rate of reconviction and the change also resulted in a lowering of educational attainment and greater likelihood of dropping out of school. Britt was surprised to hear that these results had been influential in evidence presented to the Scottish Parliament about increasing the age of criminal responsibility in Scotland.
Sharing work from Scotland
We presented some of the research that we've been doing as part of the Understanding Inequalities project and the Scottish Centre for Administrative Data Research (part of ADR UK). Ben described the convictions data held in Scotland in the Scottish Offenders Index (SOI) and provided some interesting illustrations of how it could potentially be used in comparative research with our Scandinavian colleagues. For example, it could help us to determine whether the recent falls in youth conviction in Scotland are due to uniquely Scottish factors – such as policy changes in Scotland – or are common across countries.
Meanwhile, Susan presented findings from the Edinburgh Study of Youth Transitions and Crime, an award-winning study using linked administrative and survey data, which highlighted the detrimental effect of early and prolonged justice system contact on young people. Our presentations showcased the great potential for policy-focused research using administrative crime data in Scotland. We also discussed the great strides that Scotland has made in terms of establishing a secure infrastructure and governance framework for linking administrative data for research purposes.
We still have far to go
While we thoroughly enjoyed presenting our work, it was disappointing to have to acknowledge that our ability to use the Scottish administrative data infrastructure to study crime and justice topics is severely constrained by the lack of connection between crime-related data, such as the SOI, and any other administrative datasets in Scotland.
At the conclusion of the workshop, there was a strong appetite for organising future meetings and developing collaborative work together. However, hearing about the work going on in Scandinavia and the Netherlands made us realise just how far we still have to go in Scotland. For example, criminologists in the Netherlands are currently replicating findings from a study conducted in the early 2000s, whereas we have still to get off the blocks in terms of having convictions data linked to other administrative datasets in Scotland.
As the debates about Brexit reach fever pitch, it is more important than ever that UK-based academics form strong partnerships and working relationships with our counterparts in Europe. However, it is sobering to realise how far we still have to go, in administrative data linkage terms, just to be where our European colleagues were more than a decade ago.
We left Stockholm feeling somewhat envious of the work of our European neighbours. Nevertheless, members of the Understanding Inequalities project and the Scottish Centre for Administrative Data research have been working actively with data controllers in Scotland to identify ways of bringing crime and justice data into Scotland’s data infrastructure, so we are hopeful that Scotland will be able to catch up soon!
This article was published on 07 Oct 2019