- Home
- Administrative data
- Our research
- About us
- Contact us
- News and events
- BLOG - Access to secure data during the COVID-19 pandemic - a model for the future?
- COVID-19 and Care Homes: Advances in Administrative Data Research during the pandemic
- DATA INSIGHTS: Deprivation and informal care at the end of life
- NEWS - Innovative new residential linkage tool launched
- BLOG - Spotlight on Dr Elizabeth Lemmon
- BLOG - Spotlight on Jan Savinc
- DATA INSIGHTS - Youth Movements, Social Mobility and Health Inequalities
- NEWS - New report warns of deepening poverty crisis for Scottish families
- New report on Infants Born into Care in Scotland
- BLOG - The value of social science and administrative data research in Scotland: how we are helping respond to COVID-19
- DATA INSIGHTS - Exploring illegal drug consignments in Scotland
- DATA INSIGHTS: Linking two administrative data sets about looked after children
- Virtual Conference - Data Linkage: Information to Impact
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home- No.3
- DATA INSIGHTS - Selective schools: do they improve health?
- NEWS - Understanding the dynamics of the nursing workforce: the potential of routinely collected data
- BLOG - Spotlight on Fernando Pantoja
- BLOG: Developing a cross-national research agenda on crime and convictions
- DATA INSIGHTS - The health and economic benefits of active commuting in Scotland
- BLOG - AGEING AND HOMELESSNESS IN SCOTLAND
- BLOG: Can we use linked administrative data to identify social disadvantage?
- EVENT - ADR UK Virtual Half Day event
- Event - Public data for public good: towards better understanding children's lives
- NEWS: Our role supporting the new COVID-19 research data service in Scotland
- BLOG - An Inside Job: Using Criminology, Police Data and a Lot of Nouse
- BLOG - Location of death in 2020: a changing trend from hospitals to homes
- BLOG - Seeking feedback on Research Data Scotland’s core principles via our public panel
- BLOG - Spotlight on Dr Patricio Troncoso
- BLOG - What skills, training and support are required by those wishing a career as an administrative data researcher?
- BLOG: 5 things I've learnt about working with policymakers...
- BLOG: Automating Coding for Large Historical Datasets
- BLOG: COVID-19- How increased deaths at home impact the carer community
- EVENT - Linking public sector data for research: an ADR UK showcase event
- EVENT Seminar - Administrative data for social policy research: potential and pitfalls
- NEWS - Additional funding for Understanding Children’s Lives and Outcomes
- NEWS: Police use of Fixed Penalty Notices under the Covid-19 regulations in Scotland: A new data report highlights links with deprivation and inequality
- NEWS: Police use of the new Covid-19 powers: Using administrative data to analyse and evaluate practice
- Directorship of the International Population Data Linkage Network (IPDLN) for 2021-22.
- BLOG: In the light of experience: InterRAI and the final thousand days of life
- DATA INSIGHTS: multiple health conditions and social care
- NEWS - Susan McVie elected as Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences
- SCADR relocates to the Bayes Centre
- EVENT: Four day introduction to using administrative data for social and health research
- BLOG: The value of administrative data: DALYs and the Scottish Burden of Disease study
- BLOG: Where to start with parliamentary and policy engagement
- EVENT - International Conference on Administrative Data Research, Cardiff
- EVENT - Using data to realise the potential of the 'Last 1000 days'
- EVENT: TalkingData: ADR Scotland mini-summit
- EVENT: “Let’s use data to save time, money and lives”: ADR Scotland partners gather for mini-summit
- EVENTS: ADR Scotland researchers present at international conference in Cardiff
BLOG - Seeking feedback on Research Data Scotland’s core principles via our public panel
Roger Halliday, Chief Statistician for Scottish Government and Co-Director of ADR Scotland, reflects on discussions at the recent ADR Scotland public panel on the development of the new Research Data Scotland (RDS) service.
I recently participated in the ADR Scotland public panel to discuss the development of RDS and focus specifically on the principles that underpin the new service.
The ADR Scotland public panel was created as a vital forum for understanding the views and perspectives of the public about the use of administrative data and to help to ensure research maximises public benefit in order to improve policies, services and, ultimately, lives. The panel consists of members of the public from across Scotland, from a range of different backgrounds and lived experience.
Our starting point for the discussion was the set of principles that underpin RDS’s overall mission to improve economic, social and environmental wellbeing in Scotland by enabling access to, and linkage of, data about people, places and businesses for research in the public good. These principles are:
- RDS will only enable access to data for research that is for the public good
- RDS will ensure that researchers and RDS staff can only access data once an individual’s personal identity has been removed
- RDS will ensure that all data about people, businesses or places is always kept in a controlled and secured environment
- RDS will only create a dataset if it is requested for a research programme or study that is in the public good
- All income that RDS generates will be re-invested into services to help researchers continue to access data
- Firms that access public data for the public good through RDS will share any commercial benefits back into public services
- RDS will be transparent about what data it provides access to and how it is being used for public benefit.
Data for public good
We had an engaging discussion about how ‘public good’ is defined. I explained that RDS is building upon the existing process where public benefit and privacy panels scrutinise data requests to assess their public benefit. Users of the RDS service will still need to make the case about how their proposed research project will improve wellbeing and reduce inequalities across Scotland.
We discussed how datasets held by RDS would be kept relevant for the future in light of, for example, socioeconomic movements. RDS will never hold onto data unless there is a clear purpose for doing so. However, there can also be exceptions in certain situations.
As a result of this conversation, I have now spoken to colleagues at the SAIL databank – a partner of ADR Wales – about their data retention policies. I’m going to reflect upon their advice to develop a data retention arrangement for RDS which includes the safeguards to ensure we go about holding onto data in a safe and transparent way. My intention is to join a future meeting of the public panel to provide an update on this, as well as the other areas discussed, and seek any further feedback.
Trust and transparency
One area that generated more detailed discussion was around the topic of working with the private sector and how RDS intends to work with private companies who may want to request access to data.
I highlighted that RDS will carefully review all data access requests to confirm that the requestor holds the appropriate level of accreditation, and ensure that the research is in the public good and in line with the data controller’s recognised use of their data. The first thing that any private company would have to do would be to partner with someone in the academic or public sector. Any data leaving the data safe haven would always be at an aggregate level and all research outputs will be checked to ensure they do not allow people or organisations to be identified.
To further support transparency, RDS will also develop an open register that captures uses of the data, details of who has accessed it, when and what happened to it. A condition of a researcher getting access to data would also be an agreement to publish the results. It is clear this is an area that needs careful consideration with appropriate measures put in place and this is something we will focus as we continue to develop the service.
I’m very grateful to the public panel for their time and comments and would welcome further discussion as we continue to develop RDS. Please get in touch via the RDS website if you’d like to be involved.
You can find out more about our public panel here.
This article was published on 25 Aug 2020