- Home
- Administrative data
- Our research
- About us
- Contact us
- News and events
- BLOG - Access to secure data during the Covid-19 pandemic - a model for the future?
- Covid-19 and Care Homes: Advances in Administrative Data Research during the pandemic
- DATA INSIGHTS -Deprivation and informal care at the end of life
- NEWS - Innovative new residential linkage tool launched
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home- No.4
- DATA INSIGHTS - Youth Movements, Social Mobility and Health Inequalities
- NEWS - New report warns of deepening poverty crisis for Scottish families
- New report on Infants Born into Care in Scotland
- Spotlight on Dr Elizabeth Lemmon
- Spotlight on Jan Savinc
- BLOG - The value of social science and administrative data research in Scotland: how we are helping respond to COVID-19
- DATA INSIGHTS - Exploring illegal drug consignments in Scotland
- DATA INSIGHTS -Linking two administrative data sets about looked after children
- NEWS – ADR Scotland data ambassadors launched
- The importance of administrative data
- Virtual Conference - Data Linkage: Information to Impact
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home - No.7
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home- No.3
- DATA INSIGHTS - Investigating the effects of class composition and class size on pupils’ attainment in Scottish primary schools
- NEWS - New opportunity to join ADR Scotland’s Public Panel
- BLOG - Exploring the potential of synthetic data
- DATA INSIGHTS - Automatic Coding of Occupations: Methods to create the Scottish Historic Population Database (SHPD)
- DATA INSIGHTS - Selective schools: do they improve health?
- EVENT - Active Travel: New Data, New Insights
- EVENT - Holyrood Evidence Week: Doing Data Better for Policy and Public Good
- BLOG - Geospatial Ambitions
- BLOG - Taking historical death records and developing a database for future analysis
- DATA INSIGHTS - Community mortality due to Covid-19
- Future-proofing investment into administrative data research announced in Scotland
- NEWS - Understanding the dynamics of the nursing workforce: the potential of routinely collected data
- Spotlight on Katherine Falconer
- ADR Scotland publishes its strategy for 2022-2026
- BLOG: Developing a cross-national research agenda on crime and convictions
- BLOG: Working together to make a difference with data
- DATA INSIGHTS - Homelessness duration in Scotland: how long does rehousing take?
- DATA INSIGHTS - Occupation and COVID-19 deaths: Scotland in a comparative perspective
- DATA INSIGHTS -The health and economic benefits of active commuting in Scotland
- IPDLN Conference - Data linkage research: informing policy and practice
- Spotlight on Dr Evan Williams
- Spotlight on Fernando Pantoja
- Spotlight on Laurie Berrie
- ADR Scotland Winter Partnership Session - **internal event**
- BLOG - AGEING AND HOMELESSNESS IN SCOTLAND
- BLOG - Can we use linked administrative data to identify social disadvantage?
- BLOG - Commuting and its impact on health
- BLOG - The Dynamics of the Nursing Workforce in the UK: Using data to support our nurses
- BLOG: Growing up in kinship care
- DATA INSIGHTS - Analysing a season of death and excess mortality in Scotland’s past
- EVENT - ADR UK Virtual Half Day event
- Event - Public data for public good: towards better understanding children's lives
- NEWS - Data research initiative secures £90 m funding extension
- NEWS: Our role supporting the new Covid-19 research data service in Scotland
- Spotlight on Michelle K Jamieson
- Webinar - An Introduction to Looked-After Children Dataset
- BLOG - An Inside Job: Using Criminology, Police Data and a Lot of Nouse
- BLOG - Improving justice data to promote data justice in Scotland
- BLOG - Location of death in 2020: a changing trend from hospitals to homes
- BLOG - Seeking feedback on Research Data Scotland’s core principles via our public panel
- BLOG - What skills, training and support are required by those wishing a career as an administrative data researcher?
- BLOG No. 9 - Final blog in this 'deaths at home' series
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home - No. 6
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home - No.8
- BLOG SERIES - Dramatic increase in deaths at home- No.5
- BLOG: 5 things I've learnt about working with policymakers...
- BLOG: Automating Coding for Large Historical Datasets
- BLOG: COVID-19- How increased deaths at home impact the carer community
- DATA INSIGHTS -Postal deliveries of drugs in Scotland
- EVENT - 'Getting things done with data in government'
- EVENT - Linking public sector data for research: an ADR UK showcase event
- EVENT Seminar - Administrative data for social policy research: potential and pitfalls
- NEWS - Additional funding for Understanding Children’s Lives and Outcomes
- NEWS - Engaging children and young people
- NEWS: Police use of Fixed Penalty Notices under the Covid-19 regulations in Scotland: A new data report highlights links with deprivation and inequality
- NEWS: Police use of the new Covid-19 powers: Using administrative data to analyse and evaluate practice
- Research Data Scotland - New user forum
- Spotlight on Dr Patricio Troncoso
- Summary of ADR Scotland Winter Partnership session
- Directorship of the International Population Data Linkage Network (IPDLN) for 2021-22.
- BLOG: In the light of experience: InterRAI and the final thousand days of life
- Multiple health conditions and social care
- NEWS - Susan McVie elected as Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences
- SCADR relocates to the Bayes Centre
- EVENT: Four day introduction to using administrative data for social and health research
- BLOG: The value of administrative data: DALYs and the Scottish Burden of Disease study
- BLOG: Where to start with parliamentary and policy engagement
- EVENT - International Conference on Administrative Data Research, Cardiff
- EVENT - Using data to realise the potential of the 'Last 1000 days'
- EVENT: TalkingData: ADR Scotland mini-summit
- EVENT: “Let’s use data to save time, money and lives”: ADR Scotland partners gather for mini-summit
- EVENTS: ADR Scotland researchers present at international conference in Cardiff
- SafePod Network
DATA INSIGHTS -Linking two administrative data sets about looked after children
This week, Jade Hooper, Linda Cusworth and Helen Whincup share findings from their work on ‘Permanently Progressing’, one strand of which involved an innovative data linkage of The Scottish Children’s Reporter Administration (SCRA) and Children Looked After Statistics (CLAS) data (Hooper et al, 2019).
What they found
1) Across the total sample, 67% of children had records which matched as expected, leaving 33% where records either did not match or matched unexpectedly.
2) There was considerable variation across local authorities in the rate at which data matched, from 54% to 97%.
3) Two-fifths (418) of the 1,000 linked children had a previous referral recorded by SCRA. Almost 60% of the children who had a previous referral were under one year old at the time.
4) For most (88%) of these 418 children the previous referral did not lead to a Children’s Hearing.
5) For one in five children there was an appeal to the sheriff, but for the majority (81%) there was no appeal.
Why it matters
Early engagement and timely intervention is a core aim of policy and practice (Scottish Government 2015a). The linkage showed that for 418 of the 1,000 children, professionals had previously been sufficiently worried about them to make a referral to the Reporter. Almost 60% of children who had a previous referral were under one year old at the time of that referral. The Reporter had not arranged a Children’s Hearing in relation to the majority (88%) of those referrals, however subsequent concerns led to the child later becoming looked after in 2012-13.
The Permanently Progressing? study also interviewed 160 decision makers (Whincup et al 2019). They expressed concern that referrals to the sheriff led to delays and took this into account when making decisions. The linkage showed that for the majority (81%) of the 1,000 linked children there had been no appeal.
The variation in rates of linkage (54% to 97%) demonstrates that national government and local authorities may wish to reflect on their data collection procedures and quality assurance checks. This is important in meeting Scotland’s need (Scottish Government, 2015b) that data needs to be accurate if it is to be used by policymakers and strategic leaders to plan and evaluate services.
Further Information
“Permanently Progressing” is a collaboration between the universities of Stirling, York and Lancaster, with Adoption and Fostering Alliance (Scotland). For more information, links to the five reports and summaries from Phase 1, and to see what the research team are planning for Phase Two, download the full two-page briefing or visit the study website at the University of Stirling.
This study demonstrates the value of linking data derived from decision-making by the Scottish Children’s Reporter Administration and Children’s Hearings that result in children becoming looked after. For example, their ability to tease out what subsequently happened to children after referrals highlights how much this kind of analysis can support Scotland’s improvement agenda.
Such analyses highlight the fundamental need to strengthen the mechanisms that will enable such linkage to be routine for the purposes of research which can inform policy, practice and evaluation. ADR Scotland, a partnership between SCADR and Scottish Government, is currently focused on strengthening and streamlining the information governance underpinning such data usage as well as resolving the technical barriers to linking these datasets and others.
References
- Hooper, J., Cusworth, L., Whincup, H. (2019) Linking two administrative datasets about looked after children: testing feasibility and enhancing understanding. University of Stirling.
- Scottish Government (2015a) Getting it Right for Looked After Children and Young People. Early engagement, early permanence and improving the quality of care. Edinburgh: The Scottish Government.
- Scottish Government (2015b) Looked After Children Data Strategy. Edinburgh; Scottish Government.
- Whincup, H., Grant, M., Burgess, C. and Biehal, N. (2019) Decision making for children. University of Stirling.
This article was published on 05 Mar 2020